Having a background screening policy in place is a great first step—but how do you know if it’s actually working? For HR, operations, and risk management teams, conducting regular reviews of your screening program is essential to ensure it’s effective, compliant, and aligned with your organization’s goals.
At Metrodata Services, we believe in turning screening from a checkbox into a strategic asset. Here’s how to evaluate your current program and what to look for in a meaningful account review.
Key Metrics to Monitor
Start by analyzing performance data over the past 6–12 months. These metrics offer insight into efficiency, compliance, and potential risks:
-
Average Turnaround Time: How long does it take to complete background checks? Delays can slow hiring and frustrate candidates.
-
Hit Rate vs. Clear Reports: What percentage of screenings return records? High hit rates may indicate a need for role-specific filters or geographic refinements.
-
Adverse Action Tracking: Are you following proper FCRA and state guidelines when denying employment based on screening results? A missed step here can result in legal exposure.
-
Incomplete or Abandoned Checks: How often are screenings left incomplete? Frequent drop-offs can suggest workflow issues or candidate confusion.
Benchmark Against Industry Best Practices
Compare your metrics to industry benchmarks. For example:
-
Average turnaround time should typically fall between 24 and 72 hours for most checks.
-
Adverse action processes should be consistently documented and completed within the required timeframes.
-
Re-screening frequency for sensitive roles should align with risk levels and compliance needs.
If you’re not sure how your data stacks up, Metrodata can help you interpret these benchmarks based on your industry and hiring volume.
What to Ask Your Screening Partner
During an account review, ask your background screening provider the following:
-
Are there any newer tools or packages better suited to our hiring needs?
-
Are we fully compliant with current FCRA and state-specific laws (like NY’s Fair Chance Act)?
-
Can you help us identify cost-saving opportunities without reducing screening quality?
-
Do you offer flexible service models that support our regional or seasonal hiring needs?
Ready for a Smarter Screening Strategy?
With a strong regional focus across Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse, Albany, and the NYC metro area, Metrodata Services understands local hiring challenges. Our service model ensures your account review isn’t just about data—it’s about meaningful recommendations that improve outcomes.
If it’s been over a year since your last review or if you’ve never done one, it’s time. Contact Metrodata Services today to schedule a strategic account review and make sure your screening policy is doing what it’s supposed to: protecting your business and supporting smarter hiring.
Request a No-Obligation Background Screening Services Consultation